Integrating Jesuit Values in the Online Master Science (MS) in Health Economic and Clinical Outcomes Research (HECOR) Program
Addendum 1:
HECO 567 Applied Epidemiology
Module 8: Jesuit Values and Ethics in Population Health
(4/22/2018 - 4/28/2018)
In this module we will: review ethical frameworks, Jesuit/Ignatian values to post-approval "real-world," community and group-based HECOR studies.
When completed, you will be able to apply Ignatian values to evaluate the ethical implications of epidemiologic studies and population health policies
- Common Ethical Frameworks
- Epidemiology
- Public and Population Health
- Health Services Research
- Government and Private Policy
|
Assignment (or activity): title of assignment |
Points |
|---|---|
|
Read: Chapters 17, 207 Consider Review Questions Ch 17, Questions 2 and 3 |
|
|
Watch: What are values, ethics and law? 1-1 |
|
|
Watch: The Big Four 1-2 |
|
|
Read: Ignatian Values and Gifts |
|
|
Discussion: Ethics, Solidarity and Kinship in Population Health (initial post) |
25 |
|
Discussion: Ethics, Solidarity and Kinship in Population Health (response posts) |
|
|
Revised Final Project |
50 |
|
Discussion: Post Final Project |
25 |
|
Discussion: Final reflection on course (response posts) |
|
|
Student Course Evaluation |
1 |
Final Exam Week: There is not a final exam in HECO 567 Applied Epidemiology. Instead, you will be asked to complete constructive final course evaluations.
Watch: What are values, ethics and law? 1-1 with Dr. Eileen Alexander
To complete the Discussion, it is important to differentiate between personal values and professional ethics.
This short video is from HECO571. Students who have already completed that course can decide if they need to review the difference between values, law and ethical frameworks.
Watch: The Big Four 1-2 with Dr. Eileen Alexander
To complete the Discussion, it is important to understand nonmaleficence, beneficence, autonomy and justice.
This 7 minute video is from HECO571. Students who have already completed that course can decide if they need to review the four most common ethical frameworks before completing the Discussion.
Read: This section on Ignatian Values is from HECO 571. Students who have already completed that course can decide if they need to review these values, before completing the Discussion.
You have learned that ethics is a structured way to take action when several stakeholders and frameworks suggest divergent choices. Your "gut" tells you that a situation requires additional insight. Your personal experience, "frame of reference" and learned values are insufficient to address professional laws, ethics and new, frequently unique, situations.
As a first step to integrate bioethical reasoning with health outcomes research, consider the foundation of a Jesuit education. We will return to ethics and Jesuit values frequently throughout the program. For example, consider the ethical implications of being a competent analyst, supporting high-level healthcare policy decisions!
MISSION invites us to understand the history and importance of our Jesuit heritage and Ignatian spirituality. Mission focuses on the centrality of academic excellence, grounded in a Catholic faith tradition.
REFLECTION invites us to pause and consider the world around us and our place within it.
ESA: Healthcare and research require study and close reading, i.e., reflection, to pause and consider the level and sources of knowledge, as we consider our position on important issues.
DISCERNMENT invites us to be open to God's spirit as we consider our feelings and rational thought in order to make decisions and take action that will contribute good to our lives and the world around us.
ESA: Bioethics invites us to discern among different stakeholders' viewpoints, different ethical frameworks and actions, all of which are good and true.
SOLIDARITY and KINSHIP invites us to walk alongside and learn from our companions, both local and afar, as we journey through life.
ESA: As is the case at all Jesuit, Catholic universities, students and faculty are women and men working together, in solidarity for others.
SERVICE ROOTED IN JUSTICE AND LOVE invites us to invest our lives into the well-being of our neighbors, particularly those who suffer injustice.
ESA: Community service learning and field-based research projects support the quadruple aim in healthcare. For all projects we reflect on high-level research and ask, "Does this support quality healthcare? Does this make healthcare more affordable for all? Does this support access to care? Does this increase satisfaction for clinical providers and staff?"
CURA PERSONALIS invites us to care for others recognizing the uniqueness and wholeness of each person.
ESA: How shall we integrate the uniqueness of each person, patient and student with reliable and valid population-based processes, management and decisions? How shall we use predictive models to advise individuals?
MAGIS invites us to ask, "Where is the universal good?" when making decisions; it relates to the Jesuit motto, For the Greater Glory of God.
ESA: We are called to do more, to find within ourselves the strength to give a little more, work a little harder, be a little kinder, and to accept responsibility beyond basic law and our personal needs.
Read: Chapters 17, 20
Review questions: Chapter 17, #2 and 3 will help you to understand the Discussion question.
Optional Readings: These readings are examples of poorly conducted research and the long-lasting effects on scientists' solidarity and kinship with at-risk communities. I also highly recommend The Immortal Life of Henrietta Lacks (2010) by Rebecca Skloot, or the 2017 movie.
Sickle Cell Disease breakthroughs are a hard sell
Mod 8 Discussion: Ethics, Solidarity and Kinship in Population Health
Key Points and Questions:
Initial Post:
1. Reflect upon the four common ethical frameworks. Choose one framework (nonmaleficence; beneficence; autonomy; justice) to discuss. How do professional ethical frameworks help you to meet your professional responsibilities while working in outcomes research (Gordis, p. 310-315)?
2. Reflect upon the Ignatian Value of Solidarity and Kinship. Choose one of the topics in Gordis, pp. 369-373 (Investigators' Obligations to Study Subjects; Protecting Privacy and Confidentiality; Access to Data; Race and Ethnicity in Epidemiologic Studies) to address. How does the personal value of solidarity and kinship inform your professional ethical responsibilities?
Bonus point: Where was Figure 20-3 originally published and who was the cartoonist?
Response post instructions: After creating your discussion board post, respond to your classmate's post. Specifically:
- Find something your classmates wrote that you didn't include in your post. This should be something you see as being accurate and of value. Describe what this item is, and why you see it as valuable.
- Indicate how this item adds to your understanding
- Respond to at least 2 classmates
Grading:
Completeness: Were all questions answered?
Contribution to the learning of others: supports and encourages others, noticeable reference to material from readings and the HECOR published "body of knowledge" relative to your semester in the program (e.g., "As stated by..."; "In the reading...."; relevant examples and questions; full references are not needed, however, new links are welcomed)
Style, readability/listen-ability and depth of insight: Is your post written in a professional business or scientific style (your choice of professional style)?
Grammar, spelling, etc.: Is your contribution written or spoken well and grammatically correct? Were format requirements met?
Addendum 2:
HECO 631 Global Health Systems
Module 2: Introduction to Global Health and Ethics
This module introduces the wide range of national health priorities, organized delivery systems, funding sources and competing economic needs required to fulfill the functions of a health system. We define health and consider a population health approach to managing high risk, high volume, and high priority needs, and improving outcomes.
Refer to Module 2-1: Global Health
Module 2-2: Ethics, Values and Law
After completing this module, you will be able to:
- Evaluate conflicts between professional ethics, morals, values for population health outcomes
- Evaluate conflicts between professional ethics, morals, values for individual health outcomes
- Identify Jesuit and Ignatian values in population health
|
Assignment (or activity): title of assignment |
Points |
|---|---|
|
Watch: What are values, ethics and law? 1-1 with Dr. A |
|
|
Watch: The Big Four 1-2 with Dr. A |
|
|
Watch: The Ignatian Values and Gifts with Dr. A |
|
|
Read: Skolnik, Chapter 4, Ethical and Human Rights Concerns in Global Health |
|
|
Review questions: Skolnik, Chapter 4 |
|
|
Discussion: Multicultural Competency and exploring global health issues in a nation of your choice (initial post) |
25 |
|
Discussion: Multicultural Competency and exploring global health issues in a nation of your choice (response posts) |
|
|
Assignment: Journal Part 1 I suggest that you begin working on the assignment early in the week |
25 |
Watch: What are values, ethics, and law? 1-1 with Dr. Eileen Alexander
To complete the Journal Assignment, it is important to differentiate between personal values and professional ethics.
This short video is from HECO571. If you have already completed that course you can decide if you need to review the difference between, values, law and ethical frameworks.
Watch: The Big Four 1-2 with Dr. Eileen Alexander
To complete the Journal Assignment, it is important to understand nonmaleficence, beneficence, autonomy and justice.
This 7 minute video is from HECO571. If you have already completed that course you can decide if you need to review the four most common ethical frameworks, before completing the Journal Assignment.
You have learned that ethics is a structured way to take action when several stakeholders and frameworks suggest divergent choices. Your "gut" tells you that a situation requires additional insight. Your personal experience, "frame of reference" and learned values are insufficient to address professional laws, ethics and new, frequently unique, situations.
Watch: The Ignatian Values and Gifts with Dr. Eileen Alexanders
This video on Ignatian Values reprises information from HECO 571. If you have already completed that course you can decide if you need to review these values, before completing the Journal Assignment.
As a first step to integrate bioethical reasoning with population health on a global scale, consider the foundation of a Jesuit education. We will return to ethics and Jesuit values frequently throughout the program. For example, consider the ethical implications of being a competent analyst, supporting high-level healthcare policy decisions!
The Xavier Center for Mission and Identity has very nice resources describing our values.
Read: Skolnik Section, Chapter 4, Ethical and Human Rights Concerns in Global Health
The Review Questions at the end of the chapter provide applicable examples of real-world health challenges and progress. Our Ignatian heritage encourages us to reflect. These review questions provide thought provoking fuel to inspire your Journal Assignment (Questions 5, 6, 7) and your Discussion Assignment (Questions 1-3 and 8-10). This is not an assignment you need to submit.
Discussion: Multicultural Competency
Explore global health issues in a nation of your choice. Choose a nation not covered during the course to investigate (you do not need to choose the same nation as in Module 1, Part 1).
In your initial post, address these Key Points:
Choose a role and an organization to represent. This may be as student at this university, your position with your company, or you can imagine that you work for a non-profit health organization, or the World Bank.
You are speaking to the Minister of Health in a country of your choice about one or two key health issues.
In your post, state your role, your organization, and make a brief plea to address one or two health issues. Attempt to do so using culturally sensitive language.
Begin, "It's an honor to meet you, (name)..."
Response post instructions: After creating your discussion board post, respond to your classmate's post. Specifically:
- Find something your classmates wrote that you didn't include in your post. This should be something you see as being accurate and of value. Describe what this item is, and why you see it as valuable.
- Indicate how this item adds to your understanding of global health
- Respond to at least 2 classmates
Grading: Your initial post and response will be graded related to its:
- Completeness: Did you answer each key point? Did you respond to at least 2 classmates?
- Grammar, spelling, etc. Is your contribution written or spoken well and grammatically correct?
- Style, readability/listen-ability and depth of insight. Is your post written in a professional business or scientific style, you decide which. Does it demonstrate a graduate student level of insight? Is it culturally sensitive?
- Contribution to the learning of others, supports and encourages others, noticeable reference to material from readings and the HECOR published "body of knowledge" relative to your semester in the program (e.g., "As stated by..."; "In the reading...."; relevant examples and questions; full references are not needed, however, new links are welcomed)
Assignment: Journal Part 1
In your Journal entry, address these Key Points:
- Background (~100 words)
- Briefly state your role, organization, the nation and health issue/s you addressed in Discussion: Multicultural Competency
- Identify a potential source of conflict, or need for persuasion, to address this health issue with the Minister of Health. The source of conflict could be cultural, financial, intellectual property-related, or your choice.
- State the Ignatian value/s you will use to prepare for your meeting.
- State the ethical framework you will use to address this need and conflict.
- Script (~200 words)
- Write a brief script to persuade the MOH that this need can be addressed by your organization.
- Begin, "Thank you for receiving me, (name)..."
I suggest that you begin working on the assignment early in the week.
